So far, I have never been a fan of “snap-on” tracks. To me, they look plastic-ky and toy-ish on a layout. On my N-scale layout, I used Peco flex-tracks and streamline turnouts, which mean lots and lots of effort in placing the tracks and ballasting. That’s one of the fun parts of model railway (also the headache, if you do not do it right the first time)
As I explore more about Märklin AC system, I learned more about their track system. During a recent Märklin operating session, I took particular attention on how the Märklinists use C-tracks (dt. C-Gleise) and K-tracks (dt. K-Gleise). When the ballasting is done well, you won’t notice the plastic-ky look of the C-Gleise.
Märklin currently offers 2 types of 3-rail track: C-Gleis with plastic roadbed (C for “Click” as you snap them together or take them apart) and K-Gleis without roadbed (K for “Kunststoff” (plastic)). The M-Gleis (M for “Metall”) comes with metal roadbed but is not longer available via Märklin. You can still get M-Gleise from model railway flea markets. I learned that between 1969 and 1992, Märklin offered supermarket brand train sets and metal tracks under the brand name “Primex“. Both Märklin and Primex systems are fully compatible.

I bought 3 Märklin/Primex tracks and decided to do a comparison.
Overall Appearances
Märklin M-Gleis has brownish metal roadbed with white spots to resemble ballast where as C-Gleis is completed dark gray plastic. It is interesting to note that Primex M-Gleis looks overall like M-Gleis except for the white gray metal roadbed.


Thickness
From top of the rail to bottom of the roadbed, their measurements vary. In particular, Märklin and Primex M-Gleis thickness vary by 1mm (probably not noticeable for many)




Appearance on a Layout
You can find many examples of Märklin layouts with M-Gleis on the internet. Here I want to show the appearance of C-Gleis.




I think I have now another perspective of “snap-on” tracks.
Just got a set with the newer C-tracks. And I can say for sure that I hate the new click design and feel. Feels cheap and LEGO-ish. Not to mention the hassle when you want to pull them apart. They should have kept the old M-track design in my opinion. It felt way more premium and sturdy.
LikeLike
Many Märklinists still prefer M-tracks even if they are “noisiest” of the 3 types of track from Märklin. These still command some value in secondary market. I would get a piece of used track for as low as 1 Euro.
I agreed with you that the C-tracks look cheap-ish (LEGO-ish?). I have to be extra careful when transporting my module. The “tongue” or click could easily break. If you use C-track on home layout, I guess it would be less of a problem.
With increasing cost of raw materials, I expect the quality of C-track to decline over the years 😢
LikeLike